Robert William Burchfield CNZM, CBE (27 January 1923 – 5 July 2004) was a lexicographer, scholar, and writer, who edited the Oxford English Dictionary for thirty years to 1986, and was chief editor from 1971.
Education and career
Born in Whanganui, New Zealand, he studied at Wanganui Technical College and Victoria University in Wellington. After war service in the Royal Regiment of New Zealand Artillery, he graduated MA from Wellington in 1948 and won a Rhodes Scholarship to Magdalen College, Oxford University, in England, where he was tutored by C. S. Lewis. He became a Fellow of Magdalen and lecturer in English straight after graduating (1952–53), subsequently moving colleges to Christ Church (1953–57) and St Peter's (1955–79). Through C. T. Onions, the Magdalen librarian, Burchfield assisted in editing one of Onions's projects, the Oxford Dictionary of English Etymology. His preparation of an edition of the Ormulum was supervised by J. R. R. Tolkien.
Onions recommended him to Dan Davin as editor of the second Supplement to the Oxford English Dictionary, on which he worked from 1957 to 1986. He re-established the network of volunteer readers sending in records of words that had helped to create the original OED but had been allowed to fall away. In 2004, it emerged that Burchfield's second supplement had removed a large number of words that were present in the earlier 1933 supplement edited by Onions and William Craigie, which Burchfield's second supplement incorporated. Four years later the full nature of his treatment of foreign words was shown: he deleted 17 per cent of the foreign loan words and words from regional forms of English; and his coverage was not as extensive as his predecessors, especially Onions, who included 45 per cent more loanwords and World Englishes. In 2012, a book documented Burchfield's work and showed that many of the omitted words had only a single recorded usage, but their removal ran against both what was thought to be the established OED editorial practice and a perception that he had opened up the dictionary to "World English". The author of the book concerned, Sarah Ogilvie, complained that people were unfairly judging Burchfield and that her coverage had been misleadingly reported in the media.
Burchfield also participated in a 1980s BBC committee that monitored compliance with the broadcaster's policy of using received pronunciation in newscasting, before that policy was abandoned in 1989 in favor of "using announcers and newsreaders with a more representative range of accents."
In 1994 the Hamburg-based Alfred Toepfer Foundation awarded Burchfield its annual Shakespeare Prize in recognition of his life's work.
In retirement, he produced a controversial new edition, substantially rewritten and less prescriptivist, of Fowler's Modern English Usage, the long-established style guide by Henry Watson Fowler.
He lived for many years in Sutton Courtenay, and died in Abingdon-on-Thames at 81, in 2004. He married twice and had three children.
Selected works
- Supplement to the Oxford English Dictionary, 4 vols, 1972–1986
- The Spoken Word, 1981
- The English Language, 1985
- Studies in Lexicography, 1987
- Unlocking the English Language, 1989
- The Cambridge History of the English Language, Vol. 5: English in Britain and Overseas, 1994
- Editor, Fowler's Modern English Usage, Revised Edition, 1998
References
- Oxford English Dictionary website entry for Robert Burchfield, including The Independent's obituary.
- Sarah Ogilvie, "From Outlandish Words to World English: the legitimization of global varieties of English in the OED", Euralex Conference, Lorient, France, July 2004.
- Sarah Ogilvie, "Rethinking Burchfield and World Englishes" International Journal of Lexicography, 21: 23–59, 2008.
- Sarah Ogilvie, "Words of the World: A Global History of the Oxford English Dictionary", Cambridge University Press, 2013, ISBN 1107605695.
- Leslie Kaufmann, "Dictionary Dust-Up (Danchi Is Involved)", The New York Times, 28 November 2012.
- Alison Flood, "Former OED editor covertly deleted thousand of words, book claims", The Guardian, 27 November 2012.
- The Guardian books blog, 27 November 2012, Sarah Ogilvie, "Focusing on the OED's missing words is missing the point"
- Huffington Post books blog, 29 November 2012, Sarah Ogilvie, "The OED: A Truly Global Dictionary".
- Arthur, Tom (2005) [1998]. "BBC English: Changes in Policy". Concise Oxford Companion to the English Language (EPUB electronic ed.). Oxford University Press. p. 90. ISBN 978-0-19-280637-6.
- "R.W. Burchfield, Editor of Oxford Dictionary, Dies at 81 (Published 2004)". 10 July 2004. Archived from the original on 9 June 2024. Retrieved 21 December 2024.
Robert William Burchfield CNZM CBE 27 January 1923 5 July 2004 was a lexicographer scholar and writer who edited the Oxford English Dictionary for thirty years to 1986 and was chief editor from 1971 Education and careerBorn in Whanganui New Zealand he studied at Wanganui Technical College and Victoria University in Wellington After war service in the Royal Regiment of New Zealand Artillery he graduated MA from Wellington in 1948 and won a Rhodes Scholarship to Magdalen College Oxford University in England where he was tutored by C S Lewis He became a Fellow of Magdalen and lecturer in English straight after graduating 1952 53 subsequently moving colleges to Christ Church 1953 57 and St Peter s 1955 79 Through C T Onions the Magdalen librarian Burchfield assisted in editing one of Onions s projects the Oxford Dictionary of English Etymology His preparation of an edition of the Ormulum was supervised by J R R Tolkien Onions recommended him to Dan Davin as editor of the second Supplement to the Oxford English Dictionary on which he worked from 1957 to 1986 He re established the network of volunteer readers sending in records of words that had helped to create the original OED but had been allowed to fall away In 2004 it emerged that Burchfield s second supplement had removed a large number of words that were present in the earlier 1933 supplement edited by Onions and William Craigie which Burchfield s second supplement incorporated Four years later the full nature of his treatment of foreign words was shown he deleted 17 per cent of the foreign loan words and words from regional forms of English and his coverage was not as extensive as his predecessors especially Onions who included 45 per cent more loanwords and World Englishes In 2012 a book documented Burchfield s work and showed that many of the omitted words had only a single recorded usage but their removal ran against both what was thought to be the established OED editorial practice and a perception that he had opened up the dictionary to World English The author of the book concerned Sarah Ogilvie complained that people were unfairly judging Burchfield and that her coverage had been misleadingly reported in the media Burchfield also participated in a 1980s BBC committee that monitored compliance with the broadcaster s policy of using received pronunciation in newscasting before that policy was abandoned in 1989 in favor of using announcers and newsreaders with a more representative range of accents In 1994 the Hamburg based Alfred Toepfer Foundation awarded Burchfield its annual Shakespeare Prize in recognition of his life s work In retirement he produced a controversial new edition substantially rewritten and less prescriptivist of Fowler s Modern English Usage the long established style guide by Henry Watson Fowler He lived for many years in Sutton Courtenay and died in Abingdon on Thames at 81 in 2004 He married twice and had three children Selected worksSupplement to the Oxford English Dictionary 4 vols 1972 1986 The Spoken Word 1981 The English Language 1985 Studies in Lexicography 1987 Unlocking the English Language 1989 The Cambridge History of the English Language Vol 5 English in Britain and Overseas 1994 Editor Fowler s Modern English Usage Revised Edition 1998ReferencesOxford English Dictionary website entry for Robert Burchfield including The Independent s obituary Sarah Ogilvie From Outlandish Words to World English the legitimization of global varieties of English in the OED Euralex Conference Lorient France July 2004 Sarah Ogilvie Rethinking Burchfield and World Englishes International Journal of Lexicography 21 23 59 2008 Sarah Ogilvie Words of the World A Global History of the Oxford English Dictionary Cambridge University Press 2013 ISBN 1107605695 Leslie Kaufmann Dictionary Dust Up Danchi Is Involved The New York Times 28 November 2012 Alison Flood Former OED editor covertly deleted thousand of words book claims The Guardian 27 November 2012 The Guardian books blog 27 November 2012 Sarah Ogilvie Focusing on the OED s missing words is missing the point Huffington Post books blog 29 November 2012 Sarah Ogilvie The OED A Truly Global Dictionary Arthur Tom 2005 1998 BBC English Changes in Policy Concise Oxford Companion to the English Language EPUB electronic ed Oxford University Press p 90 ISBN 978 0 19 280637 6 R W Burchfield Editor of Oxford Dictionary Dies at 81 Published 2004 10 July 2004 Archived from the original on 9 June 2024 Retrieved 21 December 2024
