Phenomenology or phenomenological psychology, a sub-discipline of psychology, is the scientific study of subjective experiences. It is an approach to psychological subject matter that attempts to explain experiences from the point of view of the subject via the analysis of their written or spoken words. The approach has its roots in the phenomenological philosophical work of Edmund Husserl.
History
Early phenomenologists such as Husserl, Jean-Paul Sartre, and Maurice Merleau-Ponty conducted philosophical investigations of consciousness in the early 20th century. Their critiques of psychologism and positivism later influenced at least two main fields of contemporary psychology: the phenomenological psychological approach of the (the descriptive phenomenological method in psychology), including Amedeo Giorgi and ; and the experimental approaches associated with Francisco Varela, Shaun Gallagher, Evan Thompson, and others (embodied mind thesis). Other names associated with the movement include Jonathan Smith (interpretative phenomenological analysis), , and Wolfgang Köhler. But "an even stronger influence on psychopathology came from Heidegger (1963), particularly through (1931), Blankenburg (1971), Tellenbach (1983), Binswanger (1994), and others." Phenomenological psychologists have also figured prominently in the history of the humanistic psychology movement.
Methodology
Phenomenology is concerned with the rich qualitative description of first-person experiences. This stands in contrast to quantitative approaches which seek to operationalize, abstract and predict behavior. Following Husserl's battle-cry "back to the things themselves", a phenomenological approach seeks to avoid speculation about underlying causes, and instead emphasizes direct descriptions of phenomena, whether by means of introspection or by attentive observation of another person.
Experience
The experiencing subject can be considered to be the person or self, for purposes of convenience. In phenomenological philosophy (and in particular in the work of Husserl, Heidegger, and Merleau-Ponty), "experience" is a considerably more complex concept than it is usually taken to be in everyday use. Instead, experience (or being, or existence itself) is an "in-relation-to" phenomenon, and it is defined by qualities of directedness, embodiment, and worldliness, which are evoked by the term "Being-in-the-World".
The quality or nature of a given experience is often referred to by the term qualia, whose archetypical exemplar is "redness". For example, we might ask, "Is my experience of redness the same as yours?" While it is difficult to answer such a question in any concrete way, the concept of intersubjectivity is often used as a mechanism for understanding how it is that humans are able to empathize with one another's experiences, and indeed to engage in meaningful communication about them. The phenomenological formulation of "Being-in-the-World", where person and world are mutually constitutive, is central here.
The observer, or in some cases the interviewer, achieves this sense of understanding and feeling of relatedness to the subject's experience, through subjective analysis of the experience, and the implied thoughts and emotions that they relay in their words.
Challenges in studying subjectivity
The philosophical psychology prevalent before the end of the 19th century relied heavily on introspection. The speculations concerning the mind based on those observations were criticized by the pioneering advocates of a more scientific and objective approach to psychology, such as William James and the behaviorists Edward Thorndike, Clark Hull, John B. Watson, and B. F. Skinner. However, not everyone agrees that introspection is intrinsically problematic, such as Francisco Varela, who has trained experimental participants in the structured "introspection" of phenomenological reduction.
In the early 1970s, Amedeo Giorgi applied phenomenological theory to his development of the Descriptive Phenomenological Method in Psychology. He sought to overcome certain problems he perceived from his work in psychophysics by approaching subjective phenomena from the traditional hypothetical-deductive framework of the natural sciences. Giorgi hoped to use what he had learned from his natural science background to develop a rigorous qualitative research method. His goal was to ensure that phenomenological research was both reliable and valid and he did this by seeking to make its processes increasingly measurable.
Philosophers have long confronted the problem of "qualia". Few philosophers believe that it is possible to be sure that one person's experience of the "redness" of an object is the same as another person's, even if both persons had effectively identical genetic and experiential histories. In principle, the same difficulty arises in feelings (the subjective experience of emotion), in the experience of effort, and especially in the "meaning" of concepts. As a result, many qualitative psychologists have claimed phenomenological inquiry to be essentially a matter of "meaning-making" and thus a question to be addressed by interpretive approaches.
Applications
Psychotherapy
Carl Rogers's person-centered psychotherapy theory is based directly on the “phenomenal field” personality theory of Combs and Snygg. That theory in turn was grounded in phenomenological thinking. Rogers attempts to put a therapist in closer contact with a person by listening to the person's report of their recent subjective experiences, especially emotions of which the person is not fully aware. For example, in relationships the problem at hand is often not based around what actually happened but, instead, based on the perceptions and feelings of each individual in the relationship. “At the core of phenomenology lies the attempt to describe and understand phenomena such as caring, healing, and wholeness as experienced by individuals who have lived through them".
Recent applications
The study and practice of phenomenology continues to grow and develop today. In 2021 a study on the experiences of individuals who attended a coexistence center (CECO) was conducted using phenomenological interviews to understand the lives of the participants. After the interviews the researchers constructed a comprehensive narrative, putting their understanding of the participants experience into their own words. This process led the researchers to understand that "the CECO is a propitious space for the development of individual and collective potentialities and the valuation of constructive social relationships that facilitate and preserve the inherent tendency of people towards growth, autonomy and psychological maturation."
Another example of phenomenology in recent years is an article published in 2022 which explains how phenomenology can grow into a larger field of study if we recognize how phenomenology has the ability to make the experiences of other people more clear, bridging the gap between subjective and objective reality. It puts forth "a methodological concept of phenomenological elucidation to promote the development of phenomenology as psychology."
Critiques
In 2022 Gerhard Thonhauser published an article which critiques phenomenology in psychology for adoption of Le Bon's crowd psychology, as well as what Thonhauser calls the "disease model of emotion transfer". Thonhauser claims there is little to no evidence of Le Bon's crowd psychology framework, of which phenomenology relies on.
In a 2015 article written for the Partially Examined Life blog, Michael Burgess argues that "...the foundational problem here is that consciousness is not a container for objects; this assertion mostly derives from another: that the world itself seems to be one way but is another, thus in its initial state of “seeming to be” it cannot be itself real (that illusion is metaphysical)."
See also
- Alterity
- Association of ideas
- Associationism
- Binding problem
- Ideology
- Neurophenomenology
- Prejudice
- Stream of consciousness (psychology)
- Vertiginous question
References
- Hardy Leahy, Thomas (2001). A History of Modern Psychology. New Jersey: Prentice Hall. p. 381. ISBN 0-13-017573-0.
- Lester, Stan (1999). "An Introduction to phenomenological research".
- Giorgi, Amedeo. (1970). Psychology as a Human Science. New York : Harper & Row.
- Giorgi, Amedeo. (2009). The Descriptive Phenomenological Method in Psychology. Duquesne University Press: Pittsburgh, PA.
- Kraus, Albert (2010). "Existential a prioris and the phenomenology of schizophrenia" (PDF). Dialogues in Philosophy, Mental and Neuro Sciences. 3 (1): 1–7. Archived (PDF) from the original on 2017-03-03.
- Royce, Joseph R.; Mos, Leendert P. (1981). Humanistic Psychology: Concepts and Criticisms. New York: Plenum Press. pp. xiii–xv. ISBN 978-1-4684-1073-0.
- Langdridge, Darren (2007). Phenomenological psychology : theory, research and method. Harlow, England: Pearson Education Ltd. ISBN 978-0-13-196523-2. OCLC 72354977.
- Moran, Dermot (2019-07-04), Stanghellini, Giovanni; Broome, Matthew; Raballo, Andrea; Fernandez, Anthony Vincent (eds.), "The Phenomenological Approach", The Oxford Handbook of Phenomenological Psychopathology, Oxford University Press, pp. 204–215, doi:10.1093/oxfordhb/9780198803157.013.26, ISBN 978-0-19-880315-7, retrieved 2023-04-29
- Langdridge, D. (2006). Phenomenological psychology: theory, research and method. Harlow: Pearson.
- Tye, Michael (20 August 1997). "Qualia". In Zalta, Edward N. (ed.). The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (Summer 2018 ed.).
- Davidsen, A. S. (2013). "Qualitative research in psychology". Phenomenological Approaches in Psychology and Health Sciences. 10 (3): 318–339. doi:10.1080/14780887.2011.608466. PMC 3627202. PMID 23606810.
- Varela, F.J. (1996). Neurophenomenology: a methodological remedy to the hard problem. Journal of Consciousness Studies, 3330-350.
- "Amedeo Giorgi: A Life in Phenomenology - PhenomenologyBlog". phenomenologyblog.com. Archived from the original on 23 October 2017. Retrieved 24 April 2018.
- Tye, Michael (2018), "Qualia", in Zalta, Edward N. (ed.), The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (Summer 2018 ed.), Metaphysics Research Lab, Stanford University, retrieved 2021-01-20
- Tye, Michael (2021), "Qualia", in Zalta, Edward N. (ed.), The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (Fall 2021 ed.), Metaphysics Research Lab, Stanford University, retrieved 2021-11-16
- Seidner, Stanley S. (1989). "Köhler's Dilemma", In Issues of Language Assessment. vol 3. Ed., Stanley S.Seidner. Springfield, Il.: State Board of Education. pp. 5–6.
- Snygg, Donald; Combs, Arthur W. (1949). Individual Behavior: A New Frame of Reference for Psychology. New York: Harper & Brothers.
- Rogers, Carl R. (1951) Client-Centered Therapy. Boston: Houghton Mifflin.
- Boeree, C. George (1998). "Personality Theories (Snygg and Combs' theory)". webspace.ship.edu. Archived from the original on 7 August 2007. Retrieved 7 October 2007.
- Wojnar, D. M., & Swanson, K. M. (2007). Phenomenology: an exploration. Journal of holistic nursing, 25(3), 172-180.
- Andrade, Eberson dos Santos; Cury, Vera Engler (2021). "Investigando a Experirncia de usußrios em um Centro de Convivrncia sob a perspectiva da psicologia humanista e da fenomenologia". Revista da Abordagem Gestáltica (in Portuguese). 27 (1): 25–36. doi:10.18065/2021v27n1.3. ISSN 1809-6867.
- Watanabe, Tsuneo (2022). "How to Develop Phenomenology as Psychology: from Description to Elucidation, Exemplified Based on a Study of Dream Analysis". Integrative Psychological and Behavioral Science. 56 (4): 964–980. doi:10.1007/s12124-020-09581-w. ISSN 1932-4502. PMID 33098070. S2CID 225057758.
- Thonhauser, Gerhard (2022). "A critique of the crowd psychological heritage in early sociology, classic phenomenology and recent social psychology". Continental Philosophy Review. 55 (3): 371–389. doi:10.1007/s11007-022-09566-z. ISSN 1387-2842. PMC 8919694. PMID 35309758.
- Burgess, Michael (2015-03-26). "Phenomenology is Wrong". The Partially Examined Life Philosophy Podcast: A Philosophy Podcast and Blog. Retrieved 2023-04-29.
External links
- "Phenomenological Psychology". Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy.
Phenomenology or phenomenological psychology a sub discipline of psychology is the scientific study of subjective experiences It is an approach to psychological subject matter that attempts to explain experiences from the point of view of the subject via the analysis of their written or spoken words The approach has its roots in the phenomenological philosophical work of Edmund Husserl HistoryEarly phenomenologists such as Husserl Jean Paul Sartre and Maurice Merleau Ponty conducted philosophical investigations of consciousness in the early 20th century Their critiques of psychologism and positivism later influenced at least two main fields of contemporary psychology the phenomenological psychological approach of the the descriptive phenomenological method in psychology including Amedeo Giorgi and and the experimental approaches associated with Francisco Varela Shaun Gallagher Evan Thompson and others embodied mind thesis Other names associated with the movement include Jonathan Smith interpretative phenomenological analysis and Wolfgang Kohler But an even stronger influence on psychopathology came from Heidegger 1963 particularly through 1931 Blankenburg 1971 Tellenbach 1983 Binswanger 1994 and others Phenomenological psychologists have also figured prominently in the history of the humanistic psychology movement MethodologyPhenomenology is concerned with the rich qualitative description of first person experiences This stands in contrast to quantitative approaches which seek to operationalize abstract and predict behavior Following Husserl s battle cry back to the things themselves a phenomenological approach seeks to avoid speculation about underlying causes and instead emphasizes direct descriptions of phenomena whether by means of introspection or by attentive observation of another person Experience The experiencing subject can be considered to be the person or self for purposes of convenience In phenomenological philosophy and in particular in the work of Husserl Heidegger and Merleau Ponty experience is a considerably more complex concept than it is usually taken to be in everyday use Instead experience or being or existence itself is an in relation to phenomenon and it is defined by qualities of directedness embodiment and worldliness which are evoked by the term Being in the World The quality or nature of a given experience is often referred to by the term qualia whose archetypical exemplar is redness For example we might ask Is my experience of redness the same as yours While it is difficult to answer such a question in any concrete way the concept of intersubjectivity is often used as a mechanism for understanding how it is that humans are able to empathize with one another s experiences and indeed to engage in meaningful communication about them The phenomenological formulation of Being in the World where person and world are mutually constitutive is central here The observer or in some cases the interviewer achieves this sense of understanding and feeling of relatedness to the subject s experience through subjective analysis of the experience and the implied thoughts and emotions that they relay in their words Challenges in studying subjectivity The philosophical psychology prevalent before the end of the 19th century relied heavily on introspection The speculations concerning the mind based on those observations were criticized by the pioneering advocates of a more scientific and objective approach to psychology such as William James and the behaviorists Edward Thorndike Clark Hull John B Watson and B F Skinner However not everyone agrees that introspection is intrinsically problematic such as Francisco Varela who has trained experimental participants in the structured introspection of phenomenological reduction In the early 1970s Amedeo Giorgi applied phenomenological theory to his development of the Descriptive Phenomenological Method in Psychology He sought to overcome certain problems he perceived from his work in psychophysics by approaching subjective phenomena from the traditional hypothetical deductive framework of the natural sciences Giorgi hoped to use what he had learned from his natural science background to develop a rigorous qualitative research method His goal was to ensure that phenomenological research was both reliable and valid and he did this by seeking to make its processes increasingly measurable Philosophers have long confronted the problem of qualia Few philosophers believe that it is possible to be sure that one person s experience of the redness of an object is the same as another person s even if both persons had effectively identical genetic and experiential histories In principle the same difficulty arises in feelings the subjective experience of emotion in the experience of effort and especially in the meaning of concepts As a result many qualitative psychologists have claimed phenomenological inquiry to be essentially a matter of meaning making and thus a question to be addressed by interpretive approaches ApplicationsPsychotherapy Carl Rogers s person centered psychotherapy theory is based directly on the phenomenal field personality theory of Combs and Snygg That theory in turn was grounded in phenomenological thinking Rogers attempts to put a therapist in closer contact with a person by listening to the person s report of their recent subjective experiences especially emotions of which the person is not fully aware For example in relationships the problem at hand is often not based around what actually happened but instead based on the perceptions and feelings of each individual in the relationship At the core of phenomenology lies the attempt to describe and understand phenomena such as caring healing and wholeness as experienced by individuals who have lived through them Recent applications The study and practice of phenomenology continues to grow and develop today In 2021 a study on the experiences of individuals who attended a coexistence center CECO was conducted using phenomenological interviews to understand the lives of the participants After the interviews the researchers constructed a comprehensive narrative putting their understanding of the participants experience into their own words This process led the researchers to understand that the CECO is a propitious space for the development of individual and collective potentialities and the valuation of constructive social relationships that facilitate and preserve the inherent tendency of people towards growth autonomy and psychological maturation Another example of phenomenology in recent years is an article published in 2022 which explains how phenomenology can grow into a larger field of study if we recognize how phenomenology has the ability to make the experiences of other people more clear bridging the gap between subjective and objective reality It puts forth a methodological concept of phenomenological elucidation to promote the development of phenomenology as psychology CritiquesIn 2022 Gerhard Thonhauser published an article which critiques phenomenology in psychology for adoption of Le Bon s crowd psychology as well as what Thonhauser calls the disease model of emotion transfer Thonhauser claims there is little to no evidence of Le Bon s crowd psychology framework of which phenomenology relies on In a 2015 article written for the Partially Examined Life blog Michael Burgess argues that the foundational problem here is that consciousness is not a container for objects this assertion mostly derives from another that the world itself seems to be one way but is another thus in its initial state of seeming to be it cannot be itself real that illusion is metaphysical See alsoAlterity Association of ideas Associationism Binding problem Ideology Neurophenomenology Prejudice Stream of consciousness psychology Vertiginous questionReferencesHardy Leahy Thomas 2001 A History of Modern Psychology New Jersey Prentice Hall p 381 ISBN 0 13 017573 0 Lester Stan 1999 An Introduction to phenomenological research Giorgi Amedeo 1970 Psychology as a Human Science New York Harper amp Row Giorgi Amedeo 2009 The Descriptive Phenomenological Method in Psychology Duquesne University Press Pittsburgh PA Kraus Albert 2010 Existential a prioris and the phenomenology of schizophrenia PDF Dialogues in Philosophy Mental and Neuro Sciences 3 1 1 7 Archived PDF from the original on 2017 03 03 Royce Joseph R Mos Leendert P 1981 Humanistic Psychology Concepts and Criticisms New York Plenum Press pp xiii xv ISBN 978 1 4684 1073 0 Langdridge Darren 2007 Phenomenological psychology theory research and method Harlow England Pearson Education Ltd ISBN 978 0 13 196523 2 OCLC 72354977 Moran Dermot 2019 07 04 Stanghellini Giovanni Broome Matthew Raballo Andrea Fernandez Anthony Vincent eds The Phenomenological Approach The Oxford Handbook of Phenomenological Psychopathology Oxford University Press pp 204 215 doi 10 1093 oxfordhb 9780198803157 013 26 ISBN 978 0 19 880315 7 retrieved 2023 04 29 Langdridge D 2006 Phenomenological psychology theory research and method Harlow Pearson Tye Michael 20 August 1997 Qualia In Zalta Edward N ed The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy Summer 2018 ed Davidsen A S 2013 Qualitative research in psychology Phenomenological Approaches in Psychology and Health Sciences 10 3 318 339 doi 10 1080 14780887 2011 608466 PMC 3627202 PMID 23606810 Varela F J 1996 Neurophenomenology a methodological remedy to the hard problem Journal of Consciousness Studies 3330 350 Amedeo Giorgi A Life in Phenomenology PhenomenologyBlog phenomenologyblog com Archived from the original on 23 October 2017 Retrieved 24 April 2018 Tye Michael 2018 Qualia in Zalta Edward N ed The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy Summer 2018 ed Metaphysics Research Lab Stanford University retrieved 2021 01 20 Tye Michael 2021 Qualia in Zalta Edward N ed The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy Fall 2021 ed Metaphysics Research Lab Stanford University retrieved 2021 11 16 Seidner Stanley S 1989 Kohler s Dilemma In Issues of Language Assessment vol 3 Ed Stanley S Seidner Springfield Il State Board of Education pp 5 6 Snygg Donald Combs Arthur W 1949 Individual Behavior A New Frame of Reference for Psychology New York Harper amp Brothers Rogers Carl R 1951 Client Centered Therapy Boston Houghton Mifflin Boeree C George 1998 Personality Theories Snygg and Combs theory webspace ship edu Archived from the original on 7 August 2007 Retrieved 7 October 2007 Wojnar D M amp Swanson K M 2007 Phenomenology an exploration Journal of holistic nursing 25 3 172 180 Andrade Eberson dos Santos Cury Vera Engler 2021 Investigando a Experirncia de usussrios em um Centro de Convivrncia sob a perspectiva da psicologia humanista e da fenomenologia Revista da Abordagem Gestaltica in Portuguese 27 1 25 36 doi 10 18065 2021v27n1 3 ISSN 1809 6867 Watanabe Tsuneo 2022 How to Develop Phenomenology as Psychology from Description to Elucidation Exemplified Based on a Study of Dream Analysis Integrative Psychological and Behavioral Science 56 4 964 980 doi 10 1007 s12124 020 09581 w ISSN 1932 4502 PMID 33098070 S2CID 225057758 Thonhauser Gerhard 2022 A critique of the crowd psychological heritage in early sociology classic phenomenology and recent social psychology Continental Philosophy Review 55 3 371 389 doi 10 1007 s11007 022 09566 z ISSN 1387 2842 PMC 8919694 PMID 35309758 Burgess Michael 2015 03 26 Phenomenology is Wrong The Partially Examined Life Philosophy Podcast A Philosophy Podcast and Blog Retrieved 2023 04 29 External linksWikiquote has quotations related to Phenomenology psychology Phenomenological Psychology Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy
