Full-reserve banking

Full-reserve banking (also known as 100% reserve banking, or sovereign money system) is a system of banking where banks do not lend demand deposits and instead only lend from time deposits. It differs from fractional-reserve banking, in which banks may lend funds on deposit, while fully reserved banks would be required to keep the full amount of each customer's demand deposits in cash, available for immediate withdrawal.

Monetary reforms that included full-reserve banking have been proposed in the past, notably in 1935 by a group of economists, including Irving Fisher, under the so-called "Chicago plan" as a response to the Great Depression.

Currently, no country in the world requires full-reserve banking across primary credit institutions, although Iceland's legislature considered it in 2015 after the 2008–2011 Icelandic financial crisis. In a 2018 Swiss ballot initiative, 75% of voters voted against the Sovereign Money Initiative which had full reserve banking as a prominent component of its proposed reform of the Swiss monetary system.

Concepts

Full-reserve banking requires banks to maintain 100% reserves against demand deposits. This is a significant change from fractional-reserve banking, where only a small percentage of deposits must be on reserve.

Basic Principles

Full-reserve banking effectively splits banks into two distinct functions, described by Benes and Kumhof (2012) as the "separation of the monetary and credit functions of the banking system."

1. Custody and Transaction Services: Banks hold deposited currency as 100%-reserve deposits, transferable to third parties.
2. Investment Intermediation: Banks would become true intermediaries, transferring from savers to borrowers. Jackson and Dyson (2012) argue this separates transaction accounts and investment accounts.

Money Creation

McLeay et al. note that in the current system, "Whenever a bank makes a loan, it simultaneously creates a matching deposit in the borrower's bank account, thereby creating new money." In contrast, Sigurjonsson explains that full-reserve banking, "transfers the power to create money from commercial banks" to the central bank.

This has several implications:

1. Money Supply: Dyson et al. argue that banks would no longer be money creators and so generate less financial instability.
2. Credit Creation: Kay argues for managing maturity mismatch through markets not within financial institutions.

Account Types

Full-reserve banking proposes two distinct types of accounts, analyzed by Pennacchi (2012).

1. Transaction Accounts
   • 100% backed by reserves
   • Available for immediate withdrawal
   • May charge service fees
   • Cannot be lent
   • Legally separated from other bank activities
2. Investment Accounts
   • Fixed terms for withdrawal
   • Can be used for lending
   • May offer different risk-return profiles
   • Risk explicitly borne by depositor
   • Returns based on investment performance

History

In the 1840s, British Currency School theorists argued for 100% reserves.

In the early 20th century, classical economics was widely accepted. In the 1930s, Keynesianism gained prominence as policymakers sought solutions for the Great Depression.

Economists proposed various strategies to address financial stability, including the Chicago Plan's full-reserve banking. Irving Fisher's "The Debt-Deflation Theory of Great Depressions" (1933) analyzed how debt cycles contributed to economic instability. Fisher proposed in his 1935 "100% Money" disconnecting money and credit.

Albert G. Hart detailed in 1935 how to maintain economic stability during the transition to 100% reserves. William R. Allen recounted in 1993 how Fisher's proposals influenced banking reform discussions. Full-reserve banking did not become law.

Maurice Allais presented a 100% reserve proposal in a 1948 book.Milton Friedman advocated for 100% reserves in 1960 with A Program for Monetary Stability.

James Tobin proposed a deposit currency system in 1985 with aspects of 100% reserves.Laurence Kotlikoff called for 100% reserve banking in his 2010 book Jimmy Stewart Is Dead.

In the 2014 Money Creation and Society debate in the UK Parliament, Zac Goldsmith called for a monetary commission on full reserve banking.

Views

In favor

Economist Milton Friedman at one time advocated a 100% reserve requirement for checking accounts, and economist Laurence Kotlikoff has also called for an end to fractional-reserve banking.Austrian School economist Murray Rothbard has written that reserves of less than 100% constitute fraud on the part of banks and should be illegal, and that full-reserve banking would eliminate the risk of bank runs.Jesús Huerta de Soto, another economist of the Austrian school, has also strongly argued in favor of full-reserve banking and the outlawing of fractional reserve banking.

The financial crisis of 2007–2008 led to renewed interest in full reserve banking and sovereign money issued by a central bank. Monetary reformers point out that fractional reserve banking leads to unpayable debt, growing economic inequality, inevitable bankruptcy, and an imperative for perpetual and unsustainable economic growth.Martin Wolf, chief economist at the Financial Times, endorsed full reserve banking, saying "it would bring huge advantages".

Martin Wolf, Chief Economics Commentator at the Financial Times, argues that many people have a fundamentally flawed and oversimplified conception of what it is that banks do. Laurence Kotlikoff and Edward Leamer agree, in a paper entitled "A Banking System We Can Trust", arguing that the current financial system did not produce the benefits that have been attributed to it. Rather than simply borrowing money from savers to make loans towards investment and production, and holding "money" as a stable liability, banks in reality create credit increasingly for the purpose of acquiring existing assets. Rather than financing real productivity and investment, and generating fair asset prices, Wall Street has come to resemble a casino, in which trade volume of securities skyrockets without having positive impacts on the investment rate or economic growth. The credits and debt banks create play a role in determining how delicate the economy is in the face of crisis. For example, Wall Street caused the housing bubble by financing millions of mortgages that were outside budget constraints, which in turn decreased output by 10 percent.

Money supply problems

In The Mystery of Banking, Murray Rothbard argues that legalized fractional-reserve banking gave banks "carte blanche" to create money out of thin air. Economists that formulated the Chicago Plan following the Great Depression argue that allowing banks to have fractional reserves puts too much power in the hands of banks by allowing them to determine the amount of money in circulation by changing the amount of loans they give out.

Fractional-reserve banking fraud issues

Deposit bankers become loan bankers when they issue fake warehouse receipts that are not backed by the assets actually held, thus constituting fraud.^:97 Rothbard likens this practice to counterfeiting, with the loan banker extracting resources from the public. However, Bryan Caplan argues that fractional-reserve banking does not constitute fraud, as by Rothbard's own admission an advertised product must simply meet the "common definition" of that product believed by consumers. Caplan contends that it is part of the common definition of a modern bank to make loans against demand deposits, thus not constituting fraud.

Balance sheet fundamentals

Furthermore, Rothbard argues that fractional reserve banking is fundamentally unsound because of the timescale of a bank's balance sheet. While a typical firm should have its assets be due prior to the payment date of its liabilities, so that the liabilities can be paid, the fractional reserve deposit bank has its demand deposit liabilities due at any point the depositor chooses, and its assets, being the loans it has made with someone else's deposits, due at some later date.

Against

New fees

Some economists have noted that under full-reserve banking, because banks would not earn revenue from lending against demand deposits, depositors would have to pay fees for the services associated with checking accounts. This, it is felt, would probably be rejected by the public. However, in economies where central banks enact zero and negative interest rate policies, some writers have noted depositors are already paying to put their savings in fractional reserve banks.

Shadow banking and unregulated institutions

In their influential paper on financial crises, economists Douglas W. Diamond and Philip H. Dybvig warned that under full-reserve banking, since banks would only be permitted to lend out funds where depositors agreed to time-lock their deposits, need for extra credit would drive some borrowers to use unregulated institutions. Unregulated institutions (such as high-yield debt issuers) would take over the economically necessary role of financial intermediation and maturity transformation, therefore destabilizing the financial system and leading to more frequent financial crises.

Writing in response to various writers' support for full reserve banking, Paul Krugman stated that the idea was "certainly worth talking about", but worries that it would drive financial activity outside the banking system, into the less regulated shadow banking system.

Misses the problem

Krugman argues that the 2008 financial crisis was not largely a result of depositors attempting to withdraw deposits from commercial banks, but a large-scale run on shadow banking. As financial markets seemed to have recovered more quickly than the 'real economy', Krugman sees the recession more as a result of excess leverage and household balance-sheet issues. Neither of these issues would be addressed by a full-reserve regulation on commercial banks, he claims.

See also

• Austrian business cycle theory
• Chicago plan / The Chicago Plan Revisited
• Committee on Monetary and Economic Reform (Canada)
• Fiat money
• Fractional-reserve banking
• Monetary reform
• List of monetary reformers
• Money creation
• Narrow banking
• Positive Money
• Reserve requirement
• Hard currency
• Seigniorage
• Swiss sovereign money referendum, 2018
• Broad money

References

1. A banking revolution Jeremy Warner, UK Telegraph
2. Weisenthal, Joe. "BAN ALL THE BANKS: Here's The Wild Idea That People Are Starting To Take Seriously". Business Insider. Retrieved 2020-11-30.
3. Sigurjónsson, Frosti (2015-03-01). "Montary Reform - A Better Monetary System For Iceland" (PDF).
4. "Iceland's daring raid on fractional reserve banks". Financial Times. 2015-04-09.
5. "Iceland looks at ending boom and bust with radical money plan". The Daily Telegraph. 2015-03-31.
6. Switzerland's 'Vollgeld' banking overhaul: how reform would work
7. Atkins, Ralph (10 June 2018). "Swiss voters reject 'sovereign money' initiative". Financial Times. Archived from the original on 2022-12-10. Retrieved 2020-11-30.
8. swissinfo.ch/sb (26 July 2018). "Vote survey shows no generation gap but misunderstandings". SWI swissinfo.ch. Retrieved 2020-11-30.
9. Phillips, Ronnie J.; Minsky, Hyman P. (2016-09-16). The Chicago Plan and New Deal Banking Reform. Routledge. p. 46. ISBN 978-1-315-28663-1.
10. Goodwin, Neva; Harris, Jonathan M.; Rajkarnikar, Pratistha Joshi; Roach, Brian; Thornton, Tim B. (2024-09-25). Essentials of Economics in Context. Taylor & Francis. ISBN 978-1-040-11400-1.
11. Benes, Mr Jaromir; Kumhof, Mr Michael (2012-08-01). The Chicago Plan Revisited. International Monetary Fund. p. 4. ISBN 978-1-4755-0552-8.
12. Tobin, James (1985). "Financial Innovation and Deregulation in Perspective" (PDF). Bank of Japan Monetary and Economic Studies 3: 25.
13. Jackson, A.; Dyson, B. (2012). "Modernising Money: Why Our Monetary System is Broken and How it Can be Fixed". Modernising Money. p. 265. Retrieved 2025-01-28.
14. Michael, McLeay; Amar, Radia; Ryland, Thomas (14 March 2014). "Money Creation in the Modern Economy". Bank of England Quarterly Bulletin, Q1: 14. SSRN 2416234.
15. Sigurjonsson, Frosti (March 2015). "Monetary Reform: A Better Monetary System for Iceland" (PDF). p. 83.
16. Dyson, Ben; Hodgson, Graham; van Lerven, Frank. Sovereign Money: An Introduction (PDF). Positive Money. p. 13.
17. Kay, John. "Should we have "narrow banking"?" (PDF). London School of Economics: 222.
18. Pennacchi, George (2012-10-01). "Narrow Banking". Annual Review of Financial Economics. 4 (4): 141–159. doi:10.1146/annurev-financial-110311-101758. ISSN 1941-1367.
19. Gürkaynak, Refet S.; Wright, Jonathan H. (2023-05-09). Research Handbook of Financial Markets. Edward Elgar Publishing. ISBN 978-1-80037-532-1.
20. Ricks, Morgan (2016). The Money Problem: Rethinking Financial Regulation. University of Chicago Press. doi:10.7208/chicago/9780226330464.001.0001. ISBN 978-0-226-52812-0.
21. Lainà, Patrizio (2015). Money creation under full-reserve banking: A stock-flow consistent model (Report). Working Paper. p11
22. Mises, Ludwig Von (1990). Money, Method, and the Market Process. Ludwig von Mises Institute. ISBN 978-1-61016-387-3.
23. Wapshott, Nicholas (11 October 2011). Keynes Hayek: The Clash that Defined Modern Economics. W. W. Norton & Company. ISBN 978-0-393-08311-8.
24. Phillips, Ronnie J. (1994-12-15). The Chicago Plan & New Deal Banking Reform. M.E. Sharpe. p. 3. ISBN 978-0-7656-3267-8.
25. Fisher, Irving (1933). "The Debt-Deflation Theory of Great Depressions". Econometrica. 1 (4): 337–357. doi:10.2307/1907327. ISSN 0012-9682. JSTOR 1907327.
26. Dimand, Robert W. (2019-03-29). Irving Fisher. Springer. p. 177. ISBN 978-3-030-05177-8.
27. H., R. G. (1936). "Review of 100 Per Cent. Money". Journal of the Royal Statistical Society. 99 (2): 388–390. doi:10.2307/2980591. ISSN 0952-8385. JSTOR 2980591.
28. Lagoarde-Segot, Thomas (2023-04-13). Ecological Money and Finance: Exploring Sustainable Monetary and Financial Systems. Springer Nature. ISBN 978-3-031-14232-1.
29. Hart, Albert G. (1935-02-01). "The "Chicago Plan" of Banking Reform: I A Proposal for Making Monetary Management Effective in the United States". The Review of Economic Studies. 2 (2): 104–116. doi:10.2307/2967557. ISSN 0034-6527. JSTOR 2967557.
30. Phillips, Ronnie J. (1994-12-15). The Chicago Plan & New Deal Banking Reform. M.E. Sharpe. p. 147. ISBN 978-0-7656-3267-8.
31. Allen, William R. (Oct 1993). "Irving Fisher and the 100 Percent Reserve Proposal". The Journal of Law and Economics. 36 (2): 703–717. doi:10.1086/467295. ISSN 0022-2186.
32. Phillips, Ronnie J.; Minsky, Hyman P. (16 September 2016). The Chicago Plan and New Deal Banking Reform. Routledge. p. 164. ISBN 978-1-315-28663-1.
33. Forder, James (2019-07-05). Milton Friedman. Springer. ISBN 978-1-137-38784-4.
34. Soto, Jesús Huerta de (2006). Money, Bank Credit, and Economic Cycles. Ludwig von Mises Institute. ISBN 978-1-61016-388-0.
35. Ahiakpor, James C. W. (22 March 2021). Macroeconomic Analysis in the Classical Tradition: The Impediments Of Keynes’s Influence. Routledge. ISBN 978-1-000-36041-7.
36. "Money Creation and Society - Hansard - UK Parliament". hansard.parliament.uk. 27 February 2025.
37. Solow, Robert M. (March 28, 2002), "On the Lender of Last Resort", Financial crises, contagion, and the lender of last resort, Oxford University Press, p. 203, ISBN 978-0-19-924721-9
38. Kotlikoff, Laurence J.; Leamer, Edward (April 23, 2009). "A Banking System We Can Trust" (PDF). Forbes. Archived from the original (PDF) on June 4, 2011. Retrieved September 14, 2010 – via Boston University.
39. Rothbard, Murray N. (2008), The Mystery of Banking (PDF), Ludwig von Mises Institute, ISBN 978-1-933550-28-2, retrieved September 14, 2010
40. The Case for a 100% Gold Dollar, Murray Rothbard
41. Jesús Huerta de Soto (2012). Money, Bank Credit, and Economic Cycles (3rd ed.). Ludwig von Mises Institute. ISBN 978-1-61016-388-0. Retrieved 4 August 2013.
42. Jackson, Andrew; Dyson, Ben (2012). Modernizing Money. Why our Monetary System is Broken and how it can be Fixed. Positive Money. ISBN 978-0-9574448-0-5.
43. Weisenthal, Joe. "BAN ALL THE BANKS: Here's The Wild Idea That People Are Starting To Take Seriously". Business Insider.
44. "Martin Wolf: Banking, credit and money". CORE. 2013-11-11. Retrieved 2020-03-11.
45. Rothbard, Murray N. (2008). The mystery of banking (2nd ed.). Auburn, Ala.: Ludwig von Mises Institute. ISBN 978-1-933550-28-2. OCLC 275097518.
46. "100% Reserve Banking — The History". House of Debt. 2014-04-26. Retrieved 2020-03-17.
47. Caplan, Bryan (2011-05-12). "The Morality of Fractional Reserve Banking". Econlib. {{cite web}}: Missing or empty |url= (help)^{[unreliable source?]}
48. Rothbard, Murray N. (2008). The mystery of banking (2nd ed.). Auburn, Ala.: Ludwig von Mises Institute. ISBN 978-1-933550-28-2. OCLC 275097518.
49. White, Lawrence H. (Winter 2003). "Accounting for Fractional-Reserve Banknotes and Deposits—or, What's Twenty Quid to the Bloody Midland Bank?" (PDF). The Independent Review. 7 (3): 423–41. ISSN 1086-1653. Archived from the original (PDF) on 2015-04-29. Retrieved 2012-11-30.
50. Allen, William (October 1993). "Irving Fisher and the 100 Percent Reserve Proposal". Journal of Law and Economics. 36 (2): 703–17. doi:10.1086/467295. JSTOR 725805. S2CID 153974326.
51. Texan Gold Depository
52. Diamond, Douglas W.; Philip H. Dybvig (Jan 1986), "Banking Theory, Deposit Insurance, and Bank Regulation", The Journal of Business, 59 (1): 55–68, doi:10.1086/296314, JSTOR 2352687, In conclusion, 100% reserve banking is a dangerous proposal that would do substantial damage to the economy by reducing the overall amount of liquidity. Furthermore, the proposal is likely to be ineffective in increasing stability since it will be impossible to control the institutions that will enter in the vacuum left when banks can no longer create liquidity. Fortunately, the political realities make it unlikely that this radical and imprudent proposal will be adopted.
53. Diamond, Douglas; Philip Dybvig (Winter 2000). "Bank Runs, Deposit Insurance, and Liquidity" (PDF). Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis Quarterly Review. 24 (1): 14–23. Retrieved 29 August 2012.
54. Krugman, Paul (April 26, 2014). "Is A Banking Ban The Answer?". New York Times. Retrieved September 18, 2015.
55. "Is A Banking Ban The Answer?". Paul Krugman Blog. 2014-04-26. Retrieved 2020-03-11.

External links

• The Chicago Plan Revisited, IMF Working Paper, Jaromir Benes and Michael Kumhof, August 2012
• In Defence of Fractional Monetary Reserves (Pascal Salin)